deposit around for their secret for spuds with “ extra - crisp and delicious skin , ” too .

Brie Goldman

It ’s time to make up the debate : should you enclose sunbaked white potato vine in foil?Many swear by it , claiming that eatery transparency - wrapper , so why should n’t we ? Others passionately guard going transparency - costless , saying it was primal for the just consistency . Luckily , we have several chefs on speed dial and was able to ask the experts to help clear up the disarray : “ Should you wrap baked Irish potato in enhancer ? ”

Baked potatoes arranged on a baking sheet

Credit:Brie Goldman

Photo : Carson Downing

The Pros and Cons of Foil-Wrapped Baked Potatoes

At just 14 , Juliana Hale Test Kitchen brand managing director , lovingly retrieve her first Book of Job at “ an old - school hostelry with a eatery , ” she severalise us . There , “ the scorched potatoes were wrapped in foil , like many steak houses of that era . I imagine this was maybe because it added some bling to the plate ? ”

Besides giving the spud a showy jacket crown , thebenefits of wrapping tater in foilinclude :

On the flip side , it ’s important to consider thedrawbacks of wrapping tater in foilbefore baking :

Baked potatoes wrapped in tin foil, one partially unwrapped

Credit:Photo: Carson Downing

Should You Wrap Baked Potatoes in Foil?

All four food experts we mouth to agree that for most occasions , it ’s well toskip the hydrofoil . It all boil down to the texture . Baking the potatoes “ bare ” is key “ so they can be crispy on the exterior and fluffy on the interior , ” Donnarumma state .

“ I prefer a crispy , flavorful crust , which is best achieved by baking them uncovered , ” aver chef Brian Mooney .

There are a few exceptions to this convention , though . It can be fresh to wrap potatoes in foil if …

Just be certain to unwrap the hydrofoil ASAP after cooking or keep enhancer - wrapped potatoes ardent in an environs over 140 ° F .

The Best Method For How to Bake Potatoes, According to Chefs

After agree on going foil - spare in nearly all circumstances , our chefs also had a unanimous reception to the best room to broil potatoes . For crispy potato hide and first-rate fluffy and light flesh , follow the lead of Hale , Donnarumma , Mooney , and recipe developer Dina Deleasa Gonsar :

Tip:“You sleep together they are done when a fork easily pierces the skin , ” Gonsar says .

Now that you ’re a pro at potatoes , let ’s verbalise about how to take them over the top . Butter , fresh chive , and sour cream are always good options . To make your white potato more of a meal , consider cleave it in one-half to fill up withturkey chili , Sloppy Joemeat , barbeque volaille , pull pork , jammy egg salad , orroasted chickpeasand a drizzle oftahini .